[Logic & Sets: Practice Lab ②] 15 Killer Problems on Contrapositives & Conditions (Step-by-Step Proofs & 1:1 Twin Diagnostics)


 

Logic & Proof · Practice Lab ②

15 Killer Exam Problems on Contrapositives & Conditions with 1:1 Twin Diagnostics

From boundary parameter inclusions and syllogistic chains to formal contrapositive proofs and proofs by contradiction

🎯 [Killer Logic Problems] Yul's 3 Golden Action Principles
  • Remember "Small Shooter & Big Target": If condition p is sufficient, P ⊂ Q (Shooter points at Q). If p is necessary, Q ⊂ P (Target encloses Q). Set up subset inclusions instantly.
  • Directly Test Boundary Equal Signs: When interval boundaries overlap on a real number line, manually test endpoint equality by plugging the boundary value back into the inclusion.
  • Pivot to Contrapositive on Negations (≠) or "OR": Complex complements and unions collapse into clean equalities (=) and intersections ("AND") under contrapositive translation.

STAGE 1. Truth Values, Real Number Line Parameters & Syllogisms

[Practice Type 01] True Converse and False Contrapositive Truth Evaluation
Q P Q ⊊ P (Converse is True, Original is False)

Let P and Q be the truth sets of conditions p and q in universal set U. Find the exact subset inclusion between P and Q such that the converse of p → q is true while its contrapositive is false.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "An implication and its contrapositive share 100% of their truth value!"
• "Contrapositive is false" means the original statement p → q is false (P ⊄ Q).
• "Converse (q → p) is true" means Q ⊂ P.
Therefore, Q must be a proper subset of P (Q ⊊ P)!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $Q \subsetneq P$ (or $Q \subset P$ and $P \ne Q$)

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Logical equivalence of original and contrapositive:
Since the contrapositive is false, the original implication $p \to q$ is also false $\implies P \not\subset Q$.

2) True converse condition:
The converse statement $q \to p$ is true $\implies Q \subset P$.

3) Synthesis:
We have $Q \subset P$ while $P \not\subset Q$, which implies $P \ne Q$.
$\therefore \mathbf{Q \subsetneq P}$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 01] For real $x$, if the contrapositive of $p \to q$ is true while its converse is false, determine the subset relation between $P$ and $Q$.
Check Answer
Answer: $P \subsetneq Q$ (Solution: Contrapositive is true $\implies P \subset Q$; converse is false $\implies Q \not\subset P$. Thus $P \subsetneq Q$)
[Practice Type 02] Real Number Line Interval: Sufficient Condition Parameter Boundary Test
-2 a Q (Big Target Superset) 1 5 P (Small Shooter)

Given conditions p : 1 ≤ x ≤ 5 and q : -2 ≤ x ≤ a, find the minimum real value of a such that p is a sufficient condition for q.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "p is sufficient $\implies$ P is the Small Shooter completely enclosed by Q!"
• $p$ is sufficient $\implies P \subset Q$.
On the number line, interval $[1, 5]$ must be covered entirely by $[-2, a]$, requiring $5 \le a$.
• Boundary Test: If $a = 5$, $Q = [-2, 5]$, which still encloses $P = [1, 5]$. Thus, equality holds: $a \ge 5$, minimum is 5.
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $5$

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Meaning of sufficient condition: $p \implies q$ is true, so $P \subset Q$.

2) Interval inclusion:
$P = [1, 5]$, $Q = [-2, a]$.
Left boundary: $-2 < 1$ is always satisfied.
Right boundary: $5 \le a$.

3) Endpoint check:
When $a = 5$, $Q = [-2, 5]$ contains $P = [1, 5]$. Equality holds.
$\therefore a \ge 5$, so the minimum value of $a$ is $\mathbf{5}$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 02] For conditions $p : -1 \le x \le 3$ and $q : k \le x \le 8$, if $p$ is a sufficient condition for $q$, find the maximum real value of $k$.
Check Answer
Answer: $-1$ (Solution: $P \subset Q \implies k \le -1$. Maximum value is $-1$)
[Practice Type 03] Necessary Condition with Negations and Contrapositive Substitution Contrapositive Shift

Given conditions p : x - 3 ≠ 0 and q : x² - kx + 12 ≠ 0, find the positive constant k such that p is a necessary condition for q.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "p is necessary $\implies$ q shoots the arrow (q ⟹ p)! Then apply the contrapositive!"
1. $p$ is necessary $\implies q \implies p$ is true.
2. Both sides contain '$\ne$'. Taking the contrapositive produces $\sim p \implies \sim q$!
3. $\sim p : x = 3$ and $\sim q : x^2 - kx + 12 = 0$. Plugging in $x = 3$ solves $k$ in 3 seconds!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $7$

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Direction of implication:
Since $p$ is a necessary condition for $q$, the implication $q \implies p$ must be true.

2) Contrapositive transformation:
$q \implies p$ is logically equivalent to its contrapositive $\sim p \implies \sim q$.
• $\sim p : x - 3 = 0 \iff x = 3$
• $\sim q : x^2 - kx + 12 = 0$

3) Substitute $x = 3$:
$3^2 - 3k + 12 = 0 \implies 21 - 3k = 0 \implies k = \mathbf{7}$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 03] Given conditions $p : x - 2 \ne 0$ and $q : x^2 + ax - 10 \ne 0$, if $p$ is a necessary condition for $q$, find constant $a$.
Check Answer
Answer: $3$ (Solution: Contrapositive $\sim p \implies \sim q$. Substituting $x = 2$ gives $4 + 2a - 10 = 0 \implies a = 3$)
[Practice Type 04] Necessary and Sufficient Conditions with Absolute Values & Quadratic Forms Equivalence Check

For real numbers a, b, select all pairs where condition p is a necessary and sufficient condition for condition q (p ⟺ q):
A. p : |a| + |b| = 0,      q : a² + b² = 0
B. p : a > b,      q : a² > b²
C. p : |a + b| = |a - b|,      q : ab = 0

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "A necessary and sufficient condition is an identical logical twin!"
• A: Both imply $a = 0$ AND $b = 0$. Identical (True).
• B: Negative counterexample ($a = 1, b = -3 \implies a > b$ but $a^2 = 1 < b^2 = 9$). False.
• C: Squaring both sides gives $(a+b)^2 = (a-b)^2 \iff 4ab = 0 \iff ab = 0$. Identical (True)!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] A, C

[Step-by-Step Solution]
• A: $|a| + |b| = 0 \iff a = 0 \text{ and } b = 0$. Also $a^2 + b^2 = 0 \iff a = 0 \text{ and } b = 0$. The truth sets are identical: $p \iff q$. (True)

• B: Let $a = 1, b = -3$. Then $a > b$ is true, but $a^2 = 1, b^2 = 9 \implies a^2 < b^2$. So $p \implies q$ fails. (False)

• C: Squaring $|a + b| = |a - b|$:
$(a + b)^2 = (a - b)^2 \implies a^2 + 2ab + b^2 = a^2 - 2ab + b^2 \iff 4ab = 0 \iff ab = 0$.
Since both statements are bidirectionally equivalent, $p \iff q$. (True)
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 04] For real $a, b$, find the equivalent condition for $p : |a| + |b| = |a + b|$.
Check Answer
Answer: $ab \ge 0$ (Solution: Square both sides: $a^2 + 2|ab| + b^2 = a^2 + 2ab + b^2 \implies |ab| = ab \iff ab \ge 0$)
[Practice Type 05] Multi-Implication Syllogistic Chains and Contrapositives Syllogism Chain
p q ~r Syllogism: p ⟹ ~r (Contrapositive: r ⟹ ~p)

For conditions p, q, r, if both statements p → q and r → ~q are true, which of the following is NOT necessarily true?
① ~q → ~p      ② q → ~r      ③ p → ~r      ④ r → ~p      ⑤ ~p → r

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "Write out contrapositives and chain them into an unbroken highway!"
• $p \to q \iff \sim q \to \sim p$
• $r \to \sim q \iff q \to \sim r$
Connecting the chain yields $p \to q \to \sim r$.
Its contrapositive chain is $r \to \sim q \to \sim p$. Any claim that reverses these directions without negating is invalid!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] ⑤

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) List true statements and contrapositives:
• $p \implies q$ is true $\implies \sim q \implies \sim p$ is true (Matches ①).
• $r \implies \sim q$ is true $\implies q \implies \sim r$ is true (Matches ②).

2) Syllogism deduction:
$p \implies q$ and $q \implies \sim r \implies p \implies \sim r$ is true (Matches ③).
Contrapositive of $p \implies \sim r$ is $r \implies \sim p$, which is also true (Matches ④).

3) Evaluation of ⑤:
$\sim p \implies r$ is the converse of $r \implies \sim p$, which cannot be guaranteed.
$\therefore$ The statement not necessarily true is ⑤.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 05] If $p \to \sim q$, $r \to s$, and $q \to r$ are all true, what condition is $p$ for $s$?
Check Answer
Answer: Neither necessary nor sufficient (Solution: $q \to r \to s \iff \sim s \to \sim q$. The inclusion between $p$ and $s$ remains undetermined)

STAGE 2. Compound Conditions & Advanced Parameter Inclusions

[Practice Type 06] Absolute Value Inequalities & Sufficient Condition Intervals Interval Parameters
-5 7 Q (Big Target Superset) 1-k 1+k P (Small Shooter)

Given conditions p : |x - 1| ≤ k (k > 0) and q : -5 ≤ x ≤ 7, find the maximum positive value of k such that p is a sufficient condition for q.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "p is sufficient $\implies$ P is the Small Shooter trapped inside Q!"
• Solving $p$ yields $1 - k \le x \le 1 + k$.
• $P \subset Q$ requires both endpoints of interval $P$ to lie inside $Q = [-5, 7]$:
  1) Left boundary: $-5 \le 1 - k \implies k \le 6$
  2) Right boundary: $1 + k \le 7 \implies k \le 6$
Taking the intersection gives $0 < k \le 6$, so the maximum value of $k$ is 6.
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $6$

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Determine truth sets:
$|x - 1| \le k \iff -k \le x - 1 \le k \iff 1 - k \le x \le 1 + k$.
$\implies P = [1 - k, 1 + k]$, while $Q = [-5, 7]$.

2) Sufficient condition condition ($P \subset Q$):
Both endpoints of $P$ must be bounded by $Q$:
• $-5 \le 1 - k \iff k \le 6$
• $1 + k \le 7 \iff k \le 6$

3) Conclusion:
Since $k > 0$, we have $0 < k \le 6$. Thus, the maximum positive value of $k$ is $\mathbf{6}$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 06] For conditions $p : |x - 2| \le a (a > 0)$ and $q : -3 \le x \le 9$, if $p$ is a sufficient condition for $q$, find the maximum positive value of $a$.
Check Answer
Answer: $5$ (Solution: $2 - a \ge -3 \implies a \le 5$, and $2 + a \le 9 \implies a \le 7$. Intersection: $a \le 5$)
[Practice Type 07] Set Operations and Necessary/Sufficient Logic Set Operations
P Q P ∩ Q = P ⟺ P ⊂ Q

Let P and Q be the truth sets of conditions p and q in universal set U. If P ∩ Q = P holds, select all correct statements from the options below:
A. p is a sufficient condition for q.
B. ~p is a necessary condition for ~q.
C. ~q is a sufficient condition for ~p.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "P ∩ Q = P identifies the smaller subset as P, meaning P ⊂ Q!"
1. $P \subset Q \implies p \implies q$ is true, so $p$ shoots the arrow $\implies$ A is true.
2. Taking complements reverses the inclusion: $Q^c \subset P^c \implies \sim q \implies \sim p$ (contrapositive).
  • B: Subject $\sim p$ is the larger superset, so it receives the arrow $\implies$ Necessary (True).
  • C: Subject $\sim q$ is the smaller subset, so it shoots the arrow $\implies$ Sufficient (True).
All three options are valid!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] A, B, C

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Set inclusion: $P \cap Q = P \iff P \subset Q$.
Hence, $p \implies q$ is unconditionally true.
$\implies$ $p$ is a sufficient condition for $q$. (A is true)

2) Contrapositive inclusion: $P \subset Q \iff Q^c \subset P^c$.
Thus, the implication $\sim q \implies \sim p$ is true.
• From $\sim p$'s perspective, it receives the arrow, making it a necessary condition for $\sim q$. (B is true)
• From $\sim q$'s perspective, it initiates the arrow, making it a sufficient condition for $\sim p$. (C is true).
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 07] If $P \cup Q = P$, determine what condition $q$ is for $p$.
Check Answer
Answer: Sufficient condition (Solution: $P \cup Q = P \iff Q \subset P \implies q \implies p$. Thus $q$ is sufficient for $p$)
[Practice Type 08] Complex Number Equivalence Checks Complex Numbers

For complex number z = a + bi (a, b are real), select all pairs where condition p is a necessary and sufficient condition for condition q (p ⟺ q):
A. p : z² is real,      q : a = 0 or b = 0
B. p : z² < 0,      q : z is a pure imaginary number
C. p : z = z̄,      q : z is real

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "Expand z² = (a² - b²) + 2abi into real and imaginary components!"
• A: $z^2$ is real $\iff 2ab = 0 \iff a = 0$ or $b = 0$. (True)
• B: $z^2 < 0 \iff a^2 - b^2 < 0$ and $2ab = 0 \iff a = 0, b \ne 0 \iff z$ is pure imaginary. (True)
• C: $z = \bar{z} \iff a + bi = a - bi \iff 2bi = 0 \iff b = 0 \iff z$ is real. (True)!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] A, B, C

[Step-by-Step Solution]
• A: $z^2 = a^2 - b^2 + 2abi$. For $z^2 \in \mathbb{R}$, imaginary part $2ab = 0 \iff a = 0 \text{ or } b = 0$. Thus $p \iff q$. (True)

• B: For $z^2 < 0$, real part $a^2 - b^2 < 0$ and imaginary part $2ab = 0$. Since $b \ne 0$, this requires $a = 0$ and $b \ne 0 \iff z$ is pure imaginary. Thus $p \iff q$. (True)

• C: $z = \bar{z} \iff a + bi = a - bi \iff 2bi = 0 \iff b = 0 \iff z \in \mathbb{R}$. Thus $p \iff q$. (True)
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 08] For complex number $z$, state the necessary and sufficient condition for $p : z + \bar{z} = 0$.
Check Answer
Answer: $z$ is pure imaginary or 0 (Solution: $2a = 0 \implies a = 0$. Real part is zero, so $z$ is pure imaginary or zero)
[Practice Type 09] Necessary Condition Interval: Counting Integer Parameters Integer Count
a-2 a+4 P (Big Target: Receives Arrow) 1 5 Q (Small Shooter)

Given conditions p : a - 2 ≤ x ≤ a + 4 and q : 1 ≤ x ≤ 5, find the number of integers a such that p is a necessary condition for q.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "p is necessary $\implies$ P is the Big Target Superset that swallows Q completely!"
• $p$ is necessary $\implies Q \subset P$ ($Q$ shoots the arrow at $P$).
• Left boundary: $a - 2 \le 1 \implies a \le 3$
• Right boundary: $a + 4 \ge 5 \implies a \ge 1$
Common range: $1 \le a \le 3$, yielding integers $a = 1, 2, 3$ (3 in total).
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $3$

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Inclusion requirement:
$p$ is a necessary condition for $q \iff q \implies p \iff Q \subset P$.

2) Number line inequality bounds:
$Q = [1, 5] \subset P = [a - 2, a + 4]$:
• Left boundary: $a - 2 \le 1 \implies a \le 3$
• Right boundary: $a + 4 \ge 5 \implies a \ge 1$

3) Integer solution:
$1 \le a \le 3$. The integers are $a = 1, 2, 3$, for a total of $\mathbf{3}$ values.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 09] For conditions $p : k - 3 \le x \le k + 5$ and $q : 2 \le x \le 6$, if $p$ is a necessary condition for $q$, find the sum of the maximum and minimum values of integer $k$.
Check Answer
Answer: $6$ (Solution: $Q \subset P \implies k - 3 \le 2 \implies k \le 5$, and $k + 5 \ge 6 \implies k \ge 1$. Interval: $1 \le k \le 5$. Sum $= 1 + 5 = 6$)
[Practice Type 10] Four-Condition Syllogisms and Equivalence Loops Equivalence Loop
p q r Equivalence Loop: p ⟺ q ⟺ r

Given conditions p, q, r, s, the statements p → q, ~r → ~q, and s → p are all true, and r is a sufficient condition for s. Determine what condition p is for r.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "When implication arrows form a closed loop, all conditions in the loop are equivalent!"
• $p \to q$
• Contrapositive of $\sim r \to \sim q$ is $q \to r$
• $r$ is sufficient for $s \implies r \to s$
• $s \to p$
Chaining them gives $p \to q \to r \to s \to p$, forming an unbroken closed cycle!
Because each condition implies every other condition, p, q, r, s are all necessary and sufficient conditions for one another.
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] Necessary and sufficient condition

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Translate premises and contrapositives:
• $p \implies q$
• $\sim r \implies \sim q \iff q \implies r$
• $r$ is sufficient for $s \implies r \implies s$
• $s \implies p$

2) Assemble the syllogism loop:
$p \implies q \implies r \implies s \implies p$.
Thus $p \implies r$ is true, and $r \implies s \implies p \implies r \implies p$ is true.

3) Conclusion:
Because $p \iff r$, condition $p$ is a necessary and sufficient condition for condition $r$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 10] If statements $p \to q$, $q \to r$, and $r \to p$ are all true, determine what condition $q$ is for $p$.
Check Answer
Answer: Necessary and sufficient condition (Solution: Forms an equivalence cycle $p \iff q \iff r$)

STAGE 3. Hardcore Killer Problems & Formal Mathematical Proofs

[Practice Type 11] Quadratic Inequalities True for All Real Numbers & Necessary Conditions Discriminant Linking
x y > 0 (All Real x) Discriminant D/4 < 0 (No x-intercepts)

For real number x, consider condition p : x² - 2kx + 9 > 0. The proposition "p is true for all real numbers x" holds if and only if -a < k < a. Find the value of positive constant a.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "'Quadratic expression > 0 for all real x' means the parabola floats completely above the x-axis!"
• The leading coefficient is positive ($1 > 0$), so the parabola opens upwards.
• To remain strictly positive for all real $x$, the curve must have no $x$-intercepts, requiring Discriminant $D < 0$!
Quarter discriminant: $\frac{D}{4} = k^2 - 9 < 0 \implies -3 < k < 3$, which immediately yields $a = 3$.
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $3$

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Geometric interpretation:
The quadratic inequality $x^2 - 2kx + 9 > 0$ must hold for all real numbers $x$.
The parabola $y = x^2 - 2kx + 9$ opens upward and never intersects the $x$-axis.

2) Discriminant condition:
$\frac{D}{4} = (-k)^2 - 1 \times 9 < 0 \implies k^2 - 9 < 0 \iff -3 < k < 3$.

3) Equate with $-a < k < a$:
Comparing with $-a < k < a$ gives positive constant $a = \mathbf{3}$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 11] Find the number of integers $k$ such that quadratic inequality $x^2 + 4kx + 16 > 0$ holds for all real numbers $x$.
Check Answer
Answer: $3$ (Solution: $\frac{D}{4} = 4k^2 - 16 < 0 \implies k^2 < 4 \implies -2 < k < 2$. Integers are $k = -1, 0, 1$, total of 3)
[Practice Type 12] Sets of Multiples: Necessary Condition & Divisor Maximum Divisors & Multiples
A₁₂ (Small Shooter) Aβ‚– (Big Target) A₁₂ ⊂ Aβ‚– ⟺ k is a divisor of 12

Let A_k denote the set of positive multiples of natural number k. Consider conditions p : x ∈ A_12 and q : x ∈ A_k. Find the maximum natural number k (where k ≠ 12) such that q is a necessary condition for p.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "For multiple sets, smaller numbers create larger sets containing more elements!"
• q is a necessary condition: q must receive the arrow from p $\implies P \subset Q$, meaning A_12 ⊂ A_k.
• For every multiple of 12 to be a multiple of $k$, $k$ must be a divisor of 12 ($\{1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 12\}$)!
The largest divisor excluding 12 is 6.
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $6$

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Necessary condition formulation:
$q$ is a necessary condition for $p \iff p \implies q \iff A_{12} \subset A_k$.

2) Properties of multiple sets:
$A_m \subset A_n$ if and only if $n$ is a divisor of $m$.
Therefore, $A_{12} \subset A_k$ requires $k$ to be a positive divisor of $12$.
Divisors of $12$: $\{1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 12\}$.

3) Maximum value ($k \ne 12$):
The greatest divisor excluding 12 is $\mathbf{6}$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 12] For multiple sets $A_k$, if $x \in A_{18}$ is a sufficient condition for $x \in A_m$, find the maximum natural number $m$ such that $m \ne 18$.
Check Answer
Answer: $9$ (Solution: $A_{18} \subset A_m \iff m$ is a divisor of 18. Greatest divisor excluding 18 is 9)
[Practice Type 13] Formal Proof by Contrapositive (Even/Odd Numbers) Formal Proof

For natural number n, prove that the proposition "If n² is even, then n is even" is true using proof by contrapositive.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "Directly moving from n² to n leads into messy square roots!"
Setting $n^2 = 2k$ forces $n = \sqrt{2k}$, stalling the proof in irrationals.
However, taking the contrapositive produces "If n is odd, then n² is odd," which lets us write $n = 2k - 1$ and directly square it into an algebraic identity. When squared terms appear in the hypothesis, contrapositive proof is always the answer!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Step-by-Step Formal Proof]

1) State the Contrapositive:
The contrapositive of the given statement is: "For natural number $n$, if $n$ is odd, then $n^2$ is odd."

2) Algebraic Proof:
Since $n$ is odd, we can represent $n$ as $n = 2k - 1$ for some natural number $k$.
Squaring both sides:
$n^2 = (2k - 1)^2 = 4k^2 - 4k + 1 = 2(2k^2 - 2k) + 1$
Since $k \in \mathbb{N}$, the term $2k^2 - 2k$ is a non-negative integer.
Thus, $n^2$ is expressible as $2 \times (\text{integer}) + 1$, meaning $n^2$ is odd.

3) Conclusion:
Since the contrapositive is true, the original proposition "If $n^2$ is even, then $n$ is even" is unconditionally true.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 13] State the contrapositive of the proposition: "For natural numbers $m, n$, if $m \times n$ is odd, then both $m$ and $n$ are odd."
Check Answer
Answer: For natural numbers $m, n$, if $m$ is even or $n$ is even, then $m \times n$ is even. (Negation of "both are odd" is "at least one is even")
[Practice Type 14] Classical Proof by Contradiction: Irrationals Contradiction Proof

Prove that the proposition "√2 is irrational (not rational)" is true using proof by contradiction.

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "The entire lever of proof by contradiction rests on the 'coprime' fraction assumption!"
• Assume the negation: $\sqrt{2} = \frac{a}{b}$, where $a, b$ are coprime natural numbers ($\gcd(a, b) = 1$).
• Algebraic deduction proves that $a$ is even, and subsequently $b$ must also be even.
• If both are even, they share common factor 2, generating a lethal contradiction against the premise that $\gcd(a, b) = 1$!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Step-by-Step Formal Proof]

1) Assume the Negation:
Assume for contradiction that $\sqrt{2}$ is rational.
Then $\sqrt{2} = \frac{a}{b}$ where $a$ and $b$ are coprime natural numbers ($\gcd(a, b) = 1$).

2) Show a is Even:
Multiplying by $b$ and squaring yields $2b^2 = a^2$.
Thus $a^2$ is an even number, which implies $a$ is even (from Type 13).
We can write $a = 2k$ for some natural number $k$.

3) Show b is Even & Deduce Contradiction:
Substitute $a = 2k$ back: $2b^2 = (2k)^2 = 4k^2 \implies b^2 = 2k^2$.
This means $b^2$ is even, so $b$ is also even.
Because both $a$ and $b$ are even, they share common divisor 2.
This directly contradicts the assumption that $a$ and $b$ are coprime.

4) Conclusion:
The assumption is false. Therefore, $\sqrt{2}$ is irrational.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 14] State the initial assumption when proving "For rational $a$ and irrational $b$, the sum $a + b$ is irrational" by contradiction.
Check Answer
Answer: Assume that $a + b$ is rational. (Solution: Setting $a + b = q \in \mathbb{Q}$ gives $b = q - a$, implying irrational $b$ equals rational minus rational, an immediate contradiction)
[Practice Type 15] Triple-Nested Real Line Inclusions Killer Exam Climax
-4 b R (Outermost Superset) a 6 Q (Middle) -1 3 P (Innermost Shooter)

For conditions p : -1 ≤ x ≤ 3, q : a ≤ x ≤ 6, and r : -4 ≤ x ≤ b, p is a sufficient condition for q, and r is a necessary condition for q. Find the minimum value of b - a. (Where a, b are real numbers)

πŸ’‘ Yul's Pro-Tip: "Chain all conditions into a 3-tier subset inclusion P ⊂ Q ⊂ R!"
• $p$ is sufficient for $q \implies P \subset Q$
• $r$ is necessary for $q \implies Q \subset R$
Combining them gives $P \subset Q \subset R$ on the real line!
• Range for $a$: $-4 \le a \le -1 \implies a_{\max} = -1$
• Range for $b$: $b \ge 6 \implies b_{\min} = 6$
To minimize $b - a$, take (Minimum $b$) - (Maximum $a$): $6 - (-1) = \mathbf{7}$!
πŸ‘‰ Reveal Answer & Step-by-Step Solution
[Answer] $7$

[Step-by-Step Solution]
1) Deduce subset inclusion chain:
• $p \implies q \iff P \subset Q$
• $q \implies r \iff Q \subset R$
$\implies \mathbf{P \subset Q \subset R}$.

2) Interval inequalities:
$P = [-1, 3]$, $Q = [a, 6]$, $R = [-4, b]$
• Left boundary: $-4 \le a \le -1$
• Right boundary: $3 \le 6 \le b \implies b \ge 6$

3) Minimize $b - a$:
$b - a$ reaches its minimum when $b$ is at its minimum and $a$ is at its maximum.
• $b_{\min} = 6$
• $a_{\max} = -1$
$\therefore (b - a)_{\min} = 6 - (-1) = \mathbf{7}$.
[1:1 Twin Diagnostic 15] For conditions $p : 1 \le x \le 4$, $q : m \le x \le 7$, and $r : -2 \le x \le n$, if $P \subset Q \subset R$, find the minimum value of $n - m$.
Check Answer
Answer: $6$ (Solution: $-2 \le m \le 1 \implies m_{\max} = 1$; $n \ge 7 \implies n_{\min} = 7$. Minimum difference $= 7 - 1 = 6$)
🌿 Words from Yul
"Killer logic problems crumble not before vague rhetoric, but through the mechanical execution of subset inclusion chains ($P \subset Q \subset R$) and contrapositive transformations."

Countless students struggle with identifying the grammatical subject in conditional statements or misjudge endpoint inequalities ($\le$) on real number lines.
However, once you internalize the "Small Shooter (Sufficient) & Big Target (Necessary)" model along with the necessity of contrapositive conversion for negations ($\ne$) and disjunctions ('OR'), mathematical logic transforms into your most dependable scoring territory.
Integrate these 15 model problem strategies into your two-split study notebook. In our next volume, we explore [Inequalities: Core Concepts ③] The Foundations of Absolute Inequalities: AM-GM and Cauchy-Schwarz.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Authentic Reference Models Beyond Basic Rulers

[Math Column]Studying Alongside Dedicated Peers: Becoming Each Other’s Lifelong Catalyst

[High School Math] Coordinate Geometry: 15 Essential Practice Problems on Section Formulas (Internal & External Division)